ForeverFFA:
Does anyone else experience the issue where they repeatedly form intense romantic bonds with people who just aren't their type sexually? If so, how do you deal? The problem isn't about being ashamed of finding fat people attractive, but that it would feel terrible to dismiss someone who is amazing to me in almost every other way except that one.
I empathise. One can't help what one finds attractive, and it can be very difficult when there is a disconnect between what one finds erotic and romantic attraction.
Ideally, one would find a partner who fits on both levels, but that can be fantastically difficult - the circles on the Venn diagram may not even touch.
It's then a matter of deciding what to do about it: (1) pursue relationships with those with whom one has a romantic connexion, and deal with the lack of erotic connexion one way or another; (2) pursue relationships with whom one finds an erotic and romantic bond, but on the understanding that finding this commonality is inherently extremely difficult; or (3) take the view that the game is not worth the candle and give up entirely.
Those three options, I think, exhaust at least the ethically acceptable options. It's a matter of a cost-benefit analysis as to which is more suited to your particular situation. The real trouble with this decision is the limited information that one has available, including about how one would really feel in each of the three situations. I had myself opted for (3) for many years until I fell for someone entirely outside this sphere - and then blew it with her. Having been reminded, albeit fleetingly, of what a real romantic connexion with someone amazing is like, it is hard to return to (3).
Whatever you decide to do, I hope that it works out for you.