God I hate that song. It's like the anthem of the town I grew up in and drives me insane. lol (Though I'm typically a Garth fan. One of few country guys I'll listen too)
Anyways....
One of the best break up songs I know of, even though it's probably not meant to be one:
1. Why Me Baby- Keith Sweat 2. Love on two way street= The Moments 3. Fire and Desire-Rick James 4. I Choose You- Willie Hutch 5. He Stop Loving her today-George Jones
Nothing compares to you by Sinead o'conner Indifference by Pearl Jam If leaving me is easy by Phil Collins Even after all this time by Jeremy Paris and Catch 22 Take your daughter to the slaughter by Iron Maiden.