General

Kit-kats and almond joy!

Can't nail it down to 1...But my alltime fav. Halloween treat wasn't candy...My Late Great Granddad on Trick or Treat night would sit out on his front porch & handmake popcorn balls right in front of the kids.He'd go thru close to #30 of popcorn!They were the size of a softball!Of course I always got 2....lol

Birthday cake >
My sibling has a birthday on Halloween, so we would celebrate that with cake, and then go out trick-'r-treating.

But traditional candy? Twix, Reeses, or Double Bubble gum

For me it’s tootsie rolls! And Hershey’s milk chocolate.

Reese’s peanut butter cups, hands down

It’s clearly peanut butter cups and everything else is playing for 2nd place, but an almond joy is always good and I only ever see Mr Goodbars and Krackles in the assorted Halloween bags, and those are ok for the novelty

My favorite is liquorish but I like the Carmel apple suckers

I like anything Reese's

Actually everything where you don't have to chew long

Snickers is an all timer, and the fun size bars are fine, but mini snickers don’t work right. The ratio is all off.