General

Is this lifestyle sinful?

Hello everyone. I’m not trying to get everyone into a debate but I am a Christian and recently been thinking about the religious ethics within feederism like how gluttony is considered a sin. I understand god made me this way and in his perfect image but I just want to see where y’all stand on this issue because obviously this is a very grey area. Thanks ????
4 years

Is this lifestyle sinful?

Zelda64:
Hello everyone. I’m not trying to get everyone into a debate but I am a Christian and recently been thinking about the religious ethics within feederism like how gluttony is considered a sin. I understand god made me this way and in his perfect image but I just want to see where y’all stand on this issue because obviously this is a very grey area. Thanks ????


Yes it is sinful. Gluttony, greed, lust. Envying others who are fatter than you.

Not to mention the adulterous nature of flirting with so many pursuers or possible feeding partners.
4 years

Is this lifestyle sinful?

Gluttony can be a sin. So can be divorce. Or eating pork. Not handling your periods the proper way. The Old Testament has a bunch of rules which were given in reply to a specific demand (later on there would be a demand for Judges), and were given to the Jewish nation.

For both Messanic Jews and other Christians the New Testament brought a new law, or a new version of the law. A more detailed one so to say. It continues the line set out in earlier in the Bible that we are sinful and that we can be saved by Grace only - full stop. So on your best day on your best behavior you're still not living up to not being sinful because not being sinful means being perfect. And you're not. I'm not. We're not. That's why we need God's grace; without it, we cannot repair or change the gap between perfect and imperfect.

Whenever the law specialists would bring out the law, Jesus would say "oh really? So what's in your heart then? Are you doing the law or doing the spirit of the law?"

In the spirit of the law eating pork can be OK for a Jewish believer and is always 100% OK for non-Jewish Christians, regardless of what it says in the Old Testamanet.

In the same vain I believe that God has made it possible to enjoy these beautiful things; from the combination of tones (music) to the joy of fattening someone up. I certainly didn't come up with these things; they are in me, they are part of my nature.

If they are bad they are no better or worse than any other sin; the Bible knows no "small" vs "big" sins. Imperfect is imperfect. I can't make things perfect. I can't make these ideas and feelings go away; not acting on them doesn't make them less sinful if they are. I can only rely on God's grace to accept me for who I am and to love me for who I am. I know I need not fear because if there is anything to pay towards that sin, it's been paid by God.

As a Christian you accepted God and God accepts you how you are, unconditionally. I guess the hardest part is for us to do so ourselves.
4 years

Is this lifestyle sinful?

allgrownup:
Gluttony can be a sin. So can be divorce. Or eating pork. Not handling your periods the proper way. The Old Testament has a bunch of rules which were given in reply to a specific demand (later on there would be a demand for Judges), and were given to the Jewish nation.

For both Messanic Jews and other Christians the New Testament brought a new law, or a new version of the law. A more detailed one so to say. It continues the line set out in earlier in the Bible that we are sinful and that we can be saved by Grace only - full stop. So on your best day on your best behavior you're still not living up to not being sinful because not being sinful means being perfect. And you're not. I'm not. We're not. That's why we need God's grace; without it, we cannot repair or change the gap between perfect and imperfect.

Whenever the law specialists would bring out the law, Jesus would say "oh really? So what's in your heart then? Are you doing the law or doing the spirit of the law?"

In the spirit of the law eating pork can be OK for a Jewish believer and is always 100% OK for non-Jewish Christians, regardless of what it says in the Old Testamanet.

In the same vain I believe that God has made it possible to enjoy these beautiful things; from the combination of tones (music) to the joy of fattening someone up. I certainly didn't come up with these things; they are in me, they are part of my nature.

If they are bad they are no better or worse than any other sin; the Bible knows no "small" vs "big" sins. Imperfect is imperfect. I can't make things perfect. I can't make these ideas and feelings go away; not acting on them doesn't make them less sinful if they are. I can only rely on God's grace to accept me for who I am and to love me for who I am. I know I need not fear because if there is anything to pay towards that sin, it's been paid by God.

As a Christian you accepted God and God accepts you how you are, unconditionally. I guess the hardest part is for us to do so ourselves.


The reason jews werent allowed to eat pork is back in the old testament days, food wasnt as clean as it later became. They didnt know eating raw meat, eggs or certain plants could kill them. What we now know are poisonous mushrooms were new to them, same as raw pork.

Fast forward thousands of years later to the new testament era, food was a bit cleaner but the kosher law remained.

Also, Roman Catholics and Christian arent perfect but are also misunderstood. We're not righteous trying not to sin, we're sinners trying to be righteous. Obviously most of us fail in that department.
4 years

Is this lifestyle sinful?

The seven sins were set up by some Catholic bishop or pope centuries ago.

Jesus, if anything, condoned partying and gluttony. Much of what he and his followers did was drink wine and eat. They were even accused of being gluttons by the Pharisees. And think of how at the first miracle, Jesus is called on to turn water into wine because the party-goers have drunk all the wine.

And in current Christianity, there is plenty of gluttony as well. I'll have to dig out an essay I wrote on this topic years ago.

Anyway, eat up. It's no sin to enjoy life.
4 years