Apologies for resurrecting a zombie thread, but I had such a dispiriting conversation tonight with a bright, sparky girl with whom I work, that I felt it might be useful for me to get some views on this issue, as I wonder if I'm being over-dramatic.
We were talking about how society judges women on their appearance. She couldn't see my point that it's unacceptable for someone to shout "fatty" at you in the street. Or rather, she could, but she wasn't prepared to put it on a par with someone shouting a racist comment or an anti-religion/disability comment. She thought, basically, that I should just get over it because they were obviously an idiot.
Her feeling was that there is freedom of speech and therefore because people will have different preferences they are entitled to say what they want. It may not be polite or make them anything other than a total tool, but the issue is more, she felt, about making women more empowered so that they're not depressed by someone making such a vile comment about them.
My issue with that is that whilst assisting women not to care what a person in a white van shouts out of his window about them is a good thing, we haven't made much progress on that front - most women are still paranoid about their appearance and most women in the public eye are chosen on the basis of/popular because of their looks.
My other issue with taking the stance that one has to just ignore it and assist women to have enough self esteem to stop it affecting them is this: it moves the problem from the person making the vile comment to the person on the receiving end. It makes it my problem to deal with being called a fatty or ugly. Which is obviously ridiculous. I'm not here to please others with the way I look. The problem lies with the person shouting that at me, and the general societal acceptance that it's okay to judge a woman on her appearance, and what's more it's perfectly fine to let her know about that judgment even if she hasn't asked. It's that sense of entitlement that if someone doesn't like the way I look, they're justified in pointing it out, even if I haven't asked their opinion.
The woman to whom I was speaking also mentioned something that made me even further depressed - she felt that someone shouting "fatty" at me wasn't the same as having a racist taunt shouted at me because "you can change being fat".
Anyway. My point is that I agree with Juicy that fat seems to be one of the last acceptable prejudices, but it's allied to the general view of most of society that it's fine to judge a person (most often a woman) on their appearance. It's not just being fat that appears to entitle people to feel they can discriminate against someone, but also if they're considered ugly. I'm sure it happens to men too, to a certain extent, but my feeling (but please tell me if you think I'm wrong) is that it's much more extreme/pervasive for women than men.
Should we just put up with people's comments and views and rise above it (they're obviously douches anyway) or should we expect more - should it be just as unacceptable to comment adversely on someone's appearance as it is to comment adversely on their race/religion/sexuality?
Is making fat/ugly-bashing a "hate crime" the solution or does that just stop people saying what they're really thinking?
Will making it not okay to criticise the way someone looks eventually help it filter through that it's not their right to judge anyone on the way they look, or is it pointless because people will always judge, they just won't be allowed to say it?
This is interesting (from another thread on here) - anyone know if this idea got any further?
telegraph.co.uk/health/healthnews/9297496/Calling-someone-fatty-could-become-a-hate-crime.html